Quick answer
Both Natures Menu Turkey and Salmon Meaty Cat Treats are 95% real meat, grain-free, and natural. The best choice depends on whether your cat prefers poultry or fish flavors.
Protein preference matters more than ingredients
The core recipe is nearly identical: both varieties contain 95% real meat, are gluten-free, and have no artificial flavors or colors. The main difference is the protein source. The Turkey blend uses turkey, chicken, and pork, while the Salmon blend uses salmon, trout, and pork.
Cats can be picky about protein. If your cat already enjoys poultry-based food or treats, the Turkey version is a safe bet. If your cat prefers fish flavors or you want to rotate proteins, the Salmon option offers a distinct taste without sacrificing the same natural, grain-free formula.
Training and medication use
Both treats are marketed as perfect for reward-based training or concealing medication. The soft, meaty texture works well for hiding pills, and the small size makes them easy to break into training rewards.
There is no texture difference between the two flavors, so your choice here is purely about which protein your cat will find more motivating during training sessions.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Turkey (Poultry Blend): Contains turkey, chicken, and pork. Best for cats that already eat poultry-based food or treats.
- Salmon (Fish Blend): Contains salmon, trout, and pork. Best for cats that prefer fish flavors or need protein rotation.
- Same formula benefits: Both are 95% real meat, grain-free, and free from artificial additives. Suitable for training and hiding medication. Check your cat's reaction to a small piece first, especially if switching proteins.
Product facts
-
Natures Menu Meaty Cat Treats - Turkey - 50g: Made with 95% real meat including turkey, chicken, and pork. Gluten-free, no artificial flavors or colors. A high meat content means your cat gets a protein-rich treat without fillers, and the poultry blend appeals to cats who prefer chicken or turkey flavors.
Natures Menu Meaty Cat Treats - Turkey - 50g
-
Natures Menu Meaty Cat Treats - Salmon - 50g: Made with 95% real meat including salmon, trout, and pork. Gluten-free, no artificial flavors or colors. The fish-forward recipe offers a different protein source for cats who enjoy salmon or need variety in their diet, while keeping the same natural, grain-free standard.
Natures Menu Meaty Cat Treats - Salmon - 50g
Which one fits your cat?
Best for
- Cats that prefer poultry flavors and already eat chicken or turkey food
- Owners who want a familiar protein source for training or medication
Not ideal for
- Cats that are sensitive to fish or prefer fish-based treats should choose the Salmon variety instead
