Quick answer
Buy a cover that is made for your specific pillow shape, then choose a fabric based on how often you wash it and how sensitive your baby's skin is. If you want the easiest cleanup, use a waterproof liner under a washable outer cover. For most parents, two covers plus one liner is the practical minimum.
Start with fit: the one measurement that matters
A nursing pillow cover only works if it matches your pillow's shape and size. Covers are cut for specific pillow models, not one-size-fits-all. Before you buy, check the pillow's brand and model name. If you have a Boppy Nursing Pillow, look for covers labeled for Boppy. If you have a different brand, measure your pillow's length and width at the widest points and compare to the cover's stated dimensions.
Boppy Nursing Pillow
Zipper placement and stretch matter too. A cover with a full zipper and some stretch is easier to put on and take off, especially after a wash. If the cover is too tight, it can pull at the seams; too loose, and it bunches under your baby's head. When in doubt, choose a cover that lists your exact pillow model rather than a generic 'fits most' claim.
Fabric choices: match the material to your routine
Fabric affects breathability, softness, and how often you need to wash. Organic cotton is a good default for babies with sensitive skin and for parents who want a natural fiber. It breathes well and gets softer with each wash. If you deal with frequent spit-up or leaky diapers, a waterproof liner under any fabric cover is more important than the cover fabric itself.
For a quick summary: choose organic cotton for everyday comfort, a waterproof liner for heavy messes, and a printed or patterned cover if you want to hide stains between washes. Avoid fabrics that feel plasticky or don't list fiber content, because they may not breathe well against your baby's skin.
How many covers do you actually need?
Two covers is the practical minimum: one on the pillow, one in the wash. If your baby spits up often or you skip laundry days, three covers plus a liner keeps you from scrambling. Extra covers also let you change the look of your nursery without buying a new pillow.
A waterproof liner is the unsung hero here. It fits between the pillow and the outer cover, so a leak doesn't soak into the pillow itself. That means you wash the liner and cover, not the whole pillow. If you only buy one accessory beyond the cover, make it the liner.
Decision rules for buying a nursing pillow cover
- Rule 1: Match the cover to your exact pillow model: Check the brand and model on your pillow's tag. Buy a cover that lists that model. If you can't find one, measure your pillow and compare to the cover's dimensions. If the cover doesn't name your pillow, treat it as a gamble.
- Rule 2: Choose fabric based on wash frequency, not looks: If you wash weekly, organic cotton is comfortable and breathable. If you wash daily or deal with frequent messes, prioritize a waterproof liner under any cover. The liner protects the pillow; the cover protects the liner.
- Rule 3: Buy at least two covers and one liner: One cover on the pillow, one in the wash, and a liner to catch leaks. This setup means you never have to use a bare pillow. Two covers plus a liner is the minimum for a calm feeding routine.
Products that fit this guide
- PBK Exclusive Nursing Pillow Covers: PBK Exclusive Nursing Pillow Covers are made from a variety of fabrics and prints and are sold exclusively at Pottery Barn Kids. If you want a cover that matches your nursery style and you already own a Boppy Nursing Pillow, these are a direct-fit option with multiple color choices.
- Boppy Nursing Pillow Protective Liner: The Boppy Nursing Pillow Protective Liner is a waterproof liner that fits snugly between the breastfeeding pillow and the printed outer cover. This liner adds a waterproof barrier so messes don't reach the pillow itself, which means less frequent deep cleaning of the pillow.
- New Boppy Nursing Pillow Organic Cotton Cover: The New Boppy Nursing Pillow Organic Cotton Cover is a 100% organic cotton, zippered, machine-washable cover in a stylish print. A good choice if you want a breathable natural fiber cover that is easy to remove and wash after feeding.
- Boppy Cozy Cabana: The Boppy Cozy Cabana is a lightweight baby bassinet for babies 0-5 months (up to 25 lb) that creates a portable rest space for supervised rest or play. Not a cover, but useful to know if you're setting up multiple rest spots and want a coordinated feeding and lounging area.
Who this guide is for
Best for
- Parents who already own a Boppy Nursing Pillow and want a replacement or extra cover
- Caregivers who want to protect their pillow with a waterproof liner
- Anyone who wants a breathable organic cotton cover for sensitive skin
Not for
- Owners of non-Boppy pillows who need a cover for a different shape or brand
- Parents looking for a new pillow; this guide only covers the cover and liner
