Quick answer
Choose the Nylon Prong Catch if you want a safety backup that keeps your leash attached when a prong collar fails. Choose the Herm Sprenger ClicLock Buckle if you want a quick-release buckle upgrade for a standard prong collar.
Safety backup vs. convenience upgrade
The Nylon Prong Catch is designed as a safety device: it attaches to your leash's bolt snap and your flat collar, keeping the leash connected even if the prong collar fails. The Herm Sprenger ClicLock Buckle replaces the center plate of a standard prong collar with a stainless steel buckle that makes the collar easier to put on and remove.
Key differences in design and fit
The Nylon Prong Catch comes in two snap options: 1/2" stainless steel snaps for smaller dogs, and 1/2" & 5/8" black coated brass snaps for larger dogs. The Herm Sprenger ClicLock Buckle is made of high-quality stainless steel, available in silver or black, and requires a compatible prong collar center plate area. Neither product is a direct replacement for the other; they serve different purposes on your dog's gear.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Primary function: Nylon Prong Catch is a safety backup; ClicLock Buckle is a convenience upgrade.
- Compatibility: Prong Catch works with any prong collar and flat collar; ClicLock Buckle requires a standard prong collar with a center plate slot. Check your collar's center plate area before choosing the ClicLock Buckle.
- Size options: Prong Catch offers 1/2" snaps for small dogs and 5/8" snaps for larger dogs; ClicLock Buckle is one size with color options. Match the snap size to your dog's collar width for the Prong Catch.
Product facts
-
Nylon Prong Catch: The Nylon Prong Catch attaches to the base of your lead's bolt snap and your flat collar, keeping your leash attached to the prong collar. This gives you a fail-safe connection if the prong collar's main attachment point fails during a walk or training session.
Nylon Prong Catch
-
Herm Sprenger ClicLock Buckle SS: The Herm Sprenger ClicLock Buckle is a patented stainless steel buckle that replaces the standard collar center plate with a simple latching mechanism. It makes a standard prong collar faster to put on and take off, which is helpful for frequent collar changes or training sessions.
Herm Sprenger ClicLock Buckle SS
Which one fits your setup?
Best for
- Dogs wearing prong collars where you want an extra safety tether (Nylon Prong Catch)
- Handlers who frequently put on or remove a prong collar and want a quick-release buckle (ClicLock Buckle)
Not for
- Dogs that already have a secure, non-prong collar attachment (Prong Catch is unnecessary)
- Prong collars without a center plate area that can accept a replacement buckle (ClicLock Buckle won't fit)
