Quick answer
Choose the Plasencia Alma del Cielo Amanecer if you want a medium-full, estate-grown Nicaraguan blend with a sunrise-inspired profile. Choose the Camacho Liberty 2012 Throwback if you value rarity and a throwback blend from a legendary limited annual release.
Flavor profile and body
The Plasencia Alma del Cielo Amanecer is a medium-full blend made entirely from estate-grown Nicaraguan tobaccos from the Finca San Julián farm at 3,500 feet. It aims for a balanced, nuanced experience that mirrors the serenity of dawn. In contrast, the Camacho Liberty 2012 Throwback is a limited-edition cigar that harks back to one of the finest Liberty releases. While the exact blend is not disclosed, Camacho Liberty releases are known for bold, complex profiles that evolve with age. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a refined, single-estate profile or a bold, collectible blend with a storied history.
Rarity and collectibility
Both cigars are limited releases, but the Camacho Liberty 2012 Throwback is exceptionally rare: annual production is capped at 2,000 boxes worldwide. This makes it a true collector's item for enthusiasts seeking something few others will have. The Plasencia Alma del Cielo Amanecer is also a limited release, but its production is less constrained, making it more accessible while still offering premium quality. If building a rare collection is your priority, the Camacho has the edge.
Value and pricing
The Plasencia Alma del Cielo Amanecer (box of 10) is priced at USD 195.25 (compared to USD 275.00), offering significant savings for a premium, estate-grown cigar. The Camacho Liberty 2012 Throwback (box of 20) is USD 244.00 (compared to USD 400.00), which breaks down to a higher per-cigar cost but reflects its extreme rarity and throwback cachet. Consider how much the story and scarcity matter to you versus getting a refined everyday premium smoke at a better per-stick price.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Flavor complexity vs. rarity: The Plasencia offers a refined, single-estate Nicaraguan blend from a specific high-altitude farm. The Camacho delivers a bold, throwback blend from a legendary limited series. Choose the Plasencia for terroir-driven nuance; choose the Camacho for a storied, hard-to-find experience.
- Accessibility vs. collectibility: The Plasencia is a limited release but more widely available. The Camacho is capped at 2,000 boxes annually, making it a true collector's item. If you want to smoke it soon, go Plasencia; if you want to cellar a rare piece of cigar history, go Camacho.
- Per-cigar value vs. per-box rarity: The Plasencia box of 10 costs USD 195.25 (about USD 19.53 per cigar) versus the Camacho box of 20 at USD 244.00 (about USD 12.20 per cigar). The Plasencia has a higher per-stick price but a lower overall box cost. The Camacho offers more cigars per box at a lower per-stick price, but its rarity adds intangible value. Compare per-cigar cost and box size to match your smoking frequency and budget.
Product facts
-
Plasencia Alma del Cielo 2025 - Amancer (Box of 10): The Plasencia Alma del Cielo Amanecer is a 6 x 60 Gordo made entirely from estate-grown Nicaraguan tobaccos from Finca San Julián at 3,500 feet elevation in Condega, Nicaragua. This single-estate sourcing gives the cigar a consistent, terroir-driven flavor profile that reflects the specific conditions of that high-altitude farm.
Plasencia Alma del Cielo 2025 - Amancer (Box of 10)
-
Camacho Liberty 2012 Throwback (Box of 20): Camacho Liberty has been an annual limited-edition release since 2002, with production limited to 2,000 boxes per year. The extreme scarcity makes the Liberty a true collector's item, and the 2012 Throwback blend connects you to one of the most celebrated releases in the series.
Camacho Liberty 2012 Throwback (Box of 20)
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Enthusiasts who want a refined, single-estate Nicaraguan blend with a medium-full body and a sunrise-inspired profile
- Collectors who value extreme rarity and a throwback blend from a legendary limited annual release
Not for
- Smokers on a tight budget who need a daily driver at a lower per-cigar cost
- Those who prefer mild, Connecticut-shade wrappers or very large ring gauges (both are 6 x 60 Gordo)
