Quick answer
Choose PureVision 6 Pack if you want a monthly silicone hydrogel lens with high oxygen transmission; choose Clariti 1 Day if you prefer the hygiene and convenience of a fresh lens every day.
Material and replacement frequency trade-off
PureVision uses balafilcon A, a silicone hydrogel material that allows more oxygen to reach your cornea, which is important for overnight wear or long hours. However, because it's a monthly lens, protein and lipid deposits can build up over time, requiring proper cleaning and storage.
Clariti 1 Day is made from somofilcon A, also a silicone hydrogel, but you discard it after each use. This eliminates the need for cleaning solutions and reduces the risk of deposit-related discomfort or infection. The trade-off is a higher per-day cost and more waste.
Cost and supply considerations
A single box of PureVision 6 Pack costs $43.79, and you need 4 boxes for an annual supply (24 lenses). That comes to about $175 per year. With Clariti 1 Day 90 Pack, a box is $70.99, and you need 8 boxes for a full year (720 lenses), totaling around $568 per year.
The monthly option is significantly cheaper annually, but it requires a daily cleaning routine. The daily option costs more but offers zero maintenance and a fresh lens every morning.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Replacement frequency: PureVision: replace monthly (6 lenses per box, 4 boxes per year). Clariti 1 Day: replace daily (90 lenses per box, 8 boxes per year).
- Material and oxygen flow: Both are silicone hydrogel. PureVision uses balafilcon A (64% silicone) for high oxygen transmission; Clariti 1 Day uses somofilcon A (44% silicone) also offering good oxygen flow. PureVision may be better for extended wear if your eye doctor approves; Clariti 1 Day is safer for daily use with no overnight wear.
- Annual cost: PureVision annual supply: ~$175. Clariti 1 Day annual supply: ~$568. If budget is a primary concern, PureVision is the more economical choice over a year.
Product facts
-
Clariti 1 Day - 90 Pack: Clariti 1 Day is a daily disposable lens made from 44% somofilcon A, a silicone hydrogel material. Silicone hydrogel provides high oxygen permeability, and daily disposal eliminates protein buildup and the need for cleaning.
Clariti 1 Day - 90 Pack
-
PureVision - 6 Pack: PureVision is a monthly lens made from 64% balafilcon A, a silicone hydrogel material. The higher silicone content supports extended wear, but the monthly replacement schedule requires diligent cleaning to prevent deposit buildup.
PureVision - 6 Pack
Which lens fits your lifestyle?
Best for
- PureVision: Wearers who want a monthly lens with high oxygen transmission and are comfortable with a daily cleaning routine.
- Clariti 1 Day: Wearers who prioritize convenience, hygiene, and zero maintenance, and are willing to pay more for daily freshness.
Not for
- PureVision: Those who dislike cleaning lenses or have a history of deposit-related eye irritation.
- Clariti 1 Day: Budget-conscious wearers who need the lowest annual cost.
