Two paths to a better period: disc or cup?
The Saalt Menstrual Disc Small and the Me Luna LARGE Classic Shorty cup solve the same problem—catching menstrual flow—but they work in fundamentally different ways. A disc sits in the vaginal fornix, just below the cervix, and doesn't use suction. A cup sits lower in the vaginal canal and relies on a seal formed by its rim. That difference drives everything else: fit, capacity, comfort, and who each option suits best.
This comparison sticks to what the catalog confirms so you can match the right product to your body and flow. Where the supplied information is silent, we say so rather than guess.
Side-by-side: Saalt Disc Small vs Me Luna LARGE Classic Shorty
- Placement: Saalt Disc sits in the vaginal fornix, just below the cervix, without suction. Me Luna cup sits in the vaginal canal and must unfold fully to form a seal.
- Capacity: Saalt Disc Small holds 30 mL (3–4 tampon capacity). The catalog does not state a volume for the Me Luna LARGE Classic Shorty.
- Recommended for: Saalt Disc Small is for light or normal flow, low cervix, teens or young adults. Me Luna LARGE is for users taller than 170 cm (5'5") with certain build and birth history combinations.
- Beginner-friendliness: Saalt Disc is described as great for beginners and period cup experts alike, with a finger notch for easy removal. The Me Luna Classic Shorty requires the cup to unfold fully; for well-toned pelvic floors, unfolding can be laborious.
- IUD compatibility: Saalt Disc doesn't use suction, making it ideal for anyone with an IUD. The catalog does not confirm IUD suitability for the Me Luna cup.
- Period sex: Saalt Disc's position in the vaginal fornix allows mess-free period sex. The catalog does not mention this use for the Me Luna cup.
Saalt Menstrual Disc Small: key facts for your decision
-
Saalt Menstrual Disc+FREE GIFT- Small: Offering up to 12 hours of leak-free protection. Long wear time means fewer changes on busy days, but individual flow and fit affect actual performance.
Saalt Menstrual Disc+FREE GIFT- Small
-
Saalt Menstrual Disc+FREE GIFT- Small: 3-4 tampon capacity, 30mL volume. A concrete capacity helps you compare against your usual tampon use, though the catalog does not give a volume for the Me Luna cup.
-
Saalt Menstrual Disc+FREE GIFT- Small: Small is recommended for: light or normal flow, low cervix, teens or young adults. If you have a low cervix or are new to internal products, the Small disc is explicitly positioned for you.
-
Saalt Menstrual Disc+FREE GIFT- Small: Featuring a finger notch to support easy menstrual disc removal. Removal can be a worry for beginners; a finger notch is a practical aid.
-
Saalt Menstrual Disc+FREE GIFT- Small: Unlike a period cup, Saalt's Menstrual Disc sits in the vaginal fornix – just below the cervix – and doesn't use any suction, making it ideal for anyone with an IUD. If you have an IUD, suction-free placement may be a key advantage over a cup.
Me Luna LARGE Classic Shorty: fit and firmness details
-
LARGE Classic Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup: The Me Luna SHORTY Cups are 30% shorter than normal menstrual cups. A shorter cup can suit a low cervix or short vaginal canal where a standard cup might feel too long.
LARGE Classic Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup
-
LARGE Classic Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup: The Me Luna SHORTY sizes are commonly used by women who have a very low cervix during menstruation, by women who have a very short vaginal canal, by women who have a prolapsed uterus. If any of these apply, the Shorty shape is designed with your anatomy in mind.
-
LARGE Classic Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup: The Large cup is suitable if you are larger than 170cm (5'5) light, medium or heavy build and have had one or two vaginal births (Medium may also suit you); also if you are over 170cm (5'5), medium or heavy build with no vaginal births; and suitable if you are over 170cm (5'5), slim or medium build and had more than two vaginal births. The LARGE size is not one-size-fits-all; use these height, build, and birth-history guidelines to check if it's your starting point.
-
LARGE Classic Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup: Me Luna Classic is pleasantly soft, but still firm enough to ensure that your menstrual cup can unfold after it is inserted. Firmness affects how easily the cup opens; Classic balances softness and unfoldability.
-
LARGE Classic Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup: For women with well-toned pelvic floor muscles, the unfolding of the cup is a bit laborious and can take some time. If you are one of these, then go for the Sport. If you do regular pelvic floor exercises, the Classic may be harder to unfold, and the Sport version may be a better match.
When a disc is the better fit
The Saalt Disc Small stands out if you have a low cervix, are a teen or young adult, or have light to normal flow. Because it sits in the vaginal fornix without suction, it's also a strong option if you have an IUD and are concerned about suction, or if you want mess-free period sex. The finger notch helps with removal, which beginners often appreciate. Keep in mind that the Small is explicitly recommended for light or normal flow; if you have heavy bleeding, the catalog mentions the disc is recommended for heavy bleeding but does not specify which size—so you may need to size up or ask for guidance.
One limitation: the catalog does not provide detailed insertion instructions for the Saalt Disc, so you'll rely on the manufacturer's guidance or support. Also, the disc cannot prevent pregnancy or STDs.
When the LARGE Classic Shorty cup makes more sense
The Me Luna LARGE Classic Shorty is a good fit if you match the size guidelines: taller than 170 cm (5'5") with a light, medium, or heavy build and one or two vaginal births; over 170 cm with a medium or heavy build and no vaginal births; or over 170 cm with a slim or medium build and more than two vaginal births. The Shorty length (30% shorter than standard cups) is particularly useful if you have a very low cervix, a short vaginal canal, or a prolapsed uterus. The Classic firmness is soft but still firm enough to unfold for most users—97% of customers find it comfortable and not too hard.
However, if you have well-toned pelvic floor muscles (for example, from Pilates), unfolding can be laborious, and the Sport version is recommended instead. Also, the catalog does not state a volume capacity for this cup, so if you need a specific milliliter rating, that information isn't available here.
Beginner checklist: disc or cup?
- If you have an IUD: The Saalt Disc is suction-free and described as ideal for IUD wearers. The Me Luna cup's IUD compatibility is not confirmed in the catalog.
- If you have a low cervix: Both products address this: the Saalt Disc Small is recommended for low cervix, and the Me Luna Shorty is 30% shorter than standard cups.
- If you want mess-free period sex: Only the Saalt Disc is noted for this use in the catalog.
- If you have heavy flow: The Saalt Disc Small is for light or normal flow; the catalog mentions the disc is recommended for heavy bleeding but doesn't specify size. The Me Luna cup's capacity is not stated, so compare carefully.
- If you have well-toned pelvic floor muscles: The Me Luna Classic may be harder to unfold; consider the Sport version. The Saalt Disc's insertion is not detailed in the catalog.
What the catalog doesn't tell you
Neither product record includes step-by-step insertion or removal instructions, so you'll need to rely on the manufacturer's guidance or contact Honour Your Flow for support. The Me Luna cup's volume capacity is not provided, which makes direct capacity comparisons difficult. The Saalt Disc's suitability for heavy flow is mentioned but not tied to a specific size. If you're unsure, reach out to [email protected]—the Me Luna record explicitly invites questions.




