Two Cups, Two Different Jobs

Choosing between the Me Luna Soft XL and the Me Luna Medium Sport Shorty means deciding what matters most for your body. Both are reusable menstrual cups from the same German manufacturer, but they solve very different problems. The Soft XL prioritizes comfort for sensitive bladders, while the Medium Sport Shorty is built for a secure seal during intense activity or for a low cervix.

At a Glance: Key Differences

  • SOFT XL Me Luna Menstrual Cup - Ring Stem: The Me Luna Soft is softer than all other Me Luna cups. It has been specifically developed for women who are particularly sensitive, especially if you find a cup can push on your bladder or partly restricts/slows urine flow. If you have ever felt a cup pressing against your bladder or noticed slower urine flow, the Soft XL's gentler material may reduce that sensation.

    SOFT XL Me Luna Menstrual Cup - Ring Stem

    SOFT XL Me Luna Menstrual Cup - Ring Stem

  • MEDIUM Sport Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup: The MeLuna Sport is our firmest menstrual cup and is 25% firmer than MeLuna Classic. The SHORTY Cups are 30% shorter than normal menstrual cups. The extra firmness helps the cup spring open under strong pelvic floor pressure, while the shorter length suits a low cervix or short vaginal canal.

    MEDIUM Sport Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup

    MEDIUM Sport Shorty Ball Me Luna Menstrual Cup

Firmness and Fit: The Core Trade-Off

The Soft XL is designed to be barely noticeable. Its softer material aims to avoid pressure on the bladder or urethra, which some users experience with firmer cups. However, the catalog notes that the Soft is best for someone who has already mastered cup insertion and removal, as the softer material can be trickier to open and seal.

The Medium Sport Shorty takes the opposite approach. Its firmness ensures the cup unfolds fully even when core muscles are engaged, making it a reliable choice for yoga, Pilates, martial arts, or any activity that works the pelvic floor. The trade-off is that a cup this firm may feel uncomfortable if the dimensions are not a good match for your body. The catalog states that the degree of softness is not the cause of pressure—it is the fit.

Length and Anatomy: Who Needs the Shorty?

The Shorty cups are 30% shorter than standard Me Luna cups. This makes them a practical option if you have a low cervix during menstruation, a short vaginal canal, or a prolapsed uterus. A standard-length cup may sit too low or cause discomfort in these cases. The Medium Sport Shorty gives you that shorter body plus the firm seal of the Sport line.

The Soft XL, by contrast, is a regular-length cup. If you have a low cervix, the extra length could lead to the cup protruding or pressing against the cervix. The catalog does not list the Soft XL as a shorty option, so it is best suited to average or higher cervix positions.

Choosing Based on Your Activity and Sensitivity

  • You are sensitive to bladder pressure: The Soft XL is the gentler choice. Its softer material is specifically formulated to reduce the feeling of a cup pushing on the bladder or slowing urine flow.
  • You have strong pelvic floor muscles or do intense core work: The Medium Sport Shorty is 25% firmer than the Classic, so it resists collapsing under muscle pressure. It is recommended for yoga, horseriding, martial arts, and similar activities.
  • You have a low cervix or short vaginal canal: The Shorty's 30% shorter body is designed for this anatomy. The Soft XL is not available in a shorty version, so the Medium Sport Shorty is the better anatomical fit.
  • You are new to menstrual cups: The Soft XL is described as trickier to insert and remove due to its softness. The Medium Sport Shorty, with its firmer material, may be easier to open and seal, but neither is marketed as a beginner cup.

What the Catalog Does Not Tell You

Neither cup's supplied evidence includes a specific volume or capacity measurement, so it is not possible to compare them on absorbency or heavy-flow suitability from the available data. If heavy flow is your primary concern, you may need to look for additional product information or contact the store directly. Similarly, the catalog does not state whether the Soft XL or Medium Sport Shorty is recommended for overnight use, so that decision depends on your personal experience with the fit.