Two square kits, one clear decision

The Scottie Square Kit and the Mushroom Square Kit are close cousins in the Mary Engelbreit needlepoint line. Both are 4 1/4" square canvases on 13 mesh, both come with Pepper Pot Silk Threads and a Size 20 John James Tapestry Needle, and both include a stitch guide covering Continental and Basketweave. The real choice comes down to which design you want to stitch and how much you want to spend.

This comparison sticks to what the catalog confirms. Where a detail is not listed—such as the exact number of thread skeins or the finished project's intended use—I'll say so rather than guess.

What each kit includes

  • Needlepoint Canvas: Scottie Square Kit: Printed canvas featuring Mary's iconic Scottie design, Pepper Pot Silk Threads in a curated palette, stitch guide for Continental and Basketweave, 13 mesh, 4 1/4" square, Size 20 John James Tapestry Needle. Confirms the Scottie kit is a complete, ready-to-stitch package with the same technical specs as the Mushroom kit.

    Needlepoint Canvas: Scottie Square Kit

    Needlepoint Canvas: Scottie Square Kit

  • Needlepoint Canvas: Mushroom Square Kit: Printed canvas featuring Mary's iconic mushroom design, Pepper Pot Silk Threads in a curated palette, stitch guide for Continental and Basketweave, 13 mesh, 4 1/4" square, Size 20 John James Tapestry Needle. Shows the Mushroom kit matches the Scottie kit in size, mesh, threads, and stitch guide—so the design is the main differentiator.

    Needlepoint Canvas: Mushroom Square Kit

    Needlepoint Canvas: Mushroom Square Kit

Where the two kits actually differ

Only two differences are confirmed by the catalog: the design on the canvas and the price. Everything else in the supplied records is identical.

  • Design: Scottie features Mary's iconic Scottie dog; Mushroom features her iconic mushroom. Both are printed on canvas and ready for stitching.
  • Price: Scottie Square Kit is listed at USD 45.00 (comparison price USD 75.00); Mushroom Square Kit is listed at USD 54.00 (comparison price USD 75.00). The Scottie kit is the lower-priced option at the time of writing.
  • Everything else: Both kits share 13 mesh, 4 1/4" square size, Pepper Pot Silk Threads, Size 20 John James Tapestry Needle, and a stitch guide covering Continental and Basketweave.

Which design suits your stitching style?

Because the technical specs are the same, your choice is mostly aesthetic. The Scottie dog is a classic Mary Engelbreit motif—if you already decorate with Scottie figures or prefer a traditional, recognizable silhouette, the Scottie Square Kit is the natural pick. The mushroom design leans a little more whimsical and organic; it may appeal if you like woodland or garden themes.

Neither kit's supplied information specifies the number of thread colors or the exact stitches beyond Continental and Basketweave. If you want to know how many colors you'll be working with, check the product page or contact the studio before ordering.

Practical points before you add to cart

  • Size: Both are 4 1/4" square—small enough to finish in a few sittings and easy to frame or finish as an ornament.
  • Mesh: 13 mesh is a medium count that works well with the included Pepper Pot Silk Threads and Size 20 needle.
  • Stitch guide: Both kits include a guide for Continental and Basketweave, so you can start even if you're new to those stitches.
  • Price: The Scottie kit is USD 45.00 and the Mushroom kit is USD 54.00, both compared to a USD 75.00 reference price.

What the catalog does not settle

The supplied records do not list the number of thread skeins, the finished project suggestions (framing, ornament, etc.), or care instructions for the finished piece. They also do not confirm whether the stitch guide includes diagrams or only written instructions. If any of these details matter to your decision, treat them as open questions rather than assuming either way.