Quick answer
Choose the Sienna Smocked Dress for easy pull-aside feeding and a flexible fit through pregnancy and postpartum; choose the Penelope Crossover Dress for a playful, put-together look with a disguised nursing panel.
Feeding access: pull-aside vs. crossover panel
The Sienna Smocked Dress uses a stretchy smocked bodice that lifts to reveal a hidden inner layer for quick pull-aside access—ideal when you need to nurse one-handed. The Penelope Crossover Dress hides its feeding panel behind a faux crossover detail: you lift the panel and pull down the stretchy fabric underneath. Both work well, but the Sienna’s design is simpler to operate in a hurry.
If you prioritize discretion when the panel is closed, the Penelope’s crossover look is less obvious as a nursing dress. The Sienna’s smocked bodice clearly signals a nursing function, though the overall silhouette remains casual and breezy.
Fit and sizing through pregnancy and postpartum
The Sienna Smocked Dress is built with an empire waist and a loose, gathered skirt, making it forgiving as your belly grows and after birth. Its stretchy smocked bodice adapts to changing bust size without needing a different size. The Penelope is a knee-length, fully lined jersey dress with a more tailored fit; it offers less room for a growing bump and may feel snugger postpartum if you prefer a looser silhouette.
Both dresses are available in multiple sizes, but the Sienna’s smocked construction gives it more flexibility for fluctuating body shapes. If you want one dress that works from early pregnancy through nursing, the Sienna is the more forgiving choice.
Fabric and seasonality
Both dresses use lightweight, breathable fabrics. The Sienna is made from a cotton-blend jersey that feels soft and airy—great for warm weather. The Penelope uses a lightweight jersey that is also breathable and fully lined, offering a bit more structure. Neither is designed for cold weather, but both can be layered with cardigans or jackets for transitional seasons.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Sienna Smocked: easier nursing access: The lift-and-pull-aside design requires fewer steps and works well one-handed. The smocked bodice also stretches to fit a changing bust without needing a different size.
- Penelope Crossover: more discreet nursing panel: The faux crossover detail hides the feeding panel, so the dress looks like a regular crossover style. It is fully lined and has a more tailored fit, which some find more polished.
- Sienna Smocked: more forgiving fit for pregnancy and postpartum: The empire waist and loose gathered skirt leave room for a growing bump and a softer silhouette after birth. The cotton-blend jersey feels airy and comfortable.
- Penelope Crossover: more structured, less forgiving: The knee-length, fitted jersey silhouette offers a put-together look but provides less room for a growing belly and may feel snugger postpartum if you prefer loose clothing. If you plan to wear the dress through late pregnancy, the Sienna is the more comfortable choice.
Product facts
-
Penelope Crossover Nursing Dress | Citrus: Made from lightweight, breathable jersey and fully lined, with an easy feeding panel disguised by a faux crossover detail. You get a put-together, playful look that doesn't scream 'nursing dress,' making it a great choice for casual outings or work-from-home days.
Penelope Crossover Nursing Dress | Citrus
-
Sienna Smocked Maternity & Nursing Dress | Light Mauve: Designed with a stretchy bodice that lifts to reveal a hidden inner layer for easy pull-aside feeding, plus an empire waist and loose, gathered skirt. The smocked bodice and flexible fit accommodate a growing belly and changing bust size, so you can wear the same dress from early pregnancy through the nursing months.
Sienna Smocked Maternity & Nursing Dress | Light Mauve
Which dress should you choose?
Best for
- Moms who want one dress that works from early pregnancy through nursing and prefer easy, one-handed nursing access: choose the Sienna Smocked Dress.
- Moms who prioritize a more discreet nursing look and a tailored, playful silhouette for casual wear: choose the Penelope Crossover Dress.
Not ideal for
- Moms who need a very fitted or structured dress for a formal event—neither dress is designed for that purpose.
- Moms who prefer a dress with sleeves or a higher neckline—both dresses have a scoop or crossover neckline.
