Quick answer
Choose the SodaPup Magnum Can for extreme power chewers who need maximum tear resistance, or the West Paw Rumbl for a softer, bouncy puzzle that's gentler on teeth and gums.
Material difference matters for your dog's chewing style
The SodaPup Magnum Can uses a proprietary magnum compound with an additive that increases tear strength, making it ideal for dogs that destroy everything. The West Paw Rumbl is made from Zogoflex Echo, a soft and bouncy material that's still tough but offers more give. If your dog is a relentless power chewer, the Magnum Can's extra tear resistance is a clear advantage. If your dog chews hard but also enjoys a toy that bounces and wobbles, the Rumbl's softer feel may be more engaging and less likely to cause tooth wear.
Treat dispensing design: puzzle vs. pop
The West Paw Rumbl features a unique fish-trap opening that challenges dogs to nudge, roll, and bounce the toy to release treats. This makes it a mental puzzle as much as a chew toy. The SodaPup Magnum Can dispenses treats when your dog rolls or bats it, but its design focuses more on durability than puzzle complexity. For dogs that get bored quickly, the Rumbl's wobbly motion and treat-release challenge may hold their interest longer. For dogs that just want to chew and occasionally get a treat, the Magnum Can's straightforward dispensing works well.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Tear resistance: SodaPup Magnum Can's magnum compound offers superior tear strength for extreme power chewers. West Paw Rumbl's Zogoflex Echo is tough but softer, so it may not hold up as long against relentless destroyers. If your dog has broken every toy, lean toward the Magnum Can.
- Engagement style: West Paw Rumbl's fish-trap opening creates a wobbly puzzle that challenges dogs mentally and physically. SodaPup Magnum Can dispenses treats when rolled, but lacks the same puzzle element. For boredom-prone dogs, the Rumbl's puzzle adds extra play value.
- Material feel: Zogoflex Echo is soft and bouncy, gentler on teeth. The Magnum compound is firmer and more rigid, which may be less forgiving during hard chewing. If you worry about tooth wear, the Rumbl's softer material is preferable.
Product facts at a glance
-
West Paw Rumbl Treat Toy: Made from West Paw's exclusive Zogoflex Echo material—soft, bouncy, and tough enough for enthusiastic chewers. The soft bounce reduces impact on teeth and gums, making it a safer choice for aggressive chewers who also like to toss toys.
West Paw Rumbl Treat Toy
-
SodaPup Magnum Can: Proprietary magnum compound has a special additive for increased tear strength; designed to withstand power chewers. If your dog has destroyed every other toy, the Magnum Can's enhanced tear resistance gives it the best chance of surviving.
SodaPup Magnum Can
Which treat toy fits your dog?
Best for
- Power chewers who destroy everything: SodaPup Magnum Can
- Dogs that enjoy puzzle toys and softer materials: West Paw Rumbl
Not for
- Dogs that need maximum tear resistance: West Paw Rumbl (choose Magnum Can instead)
- Dogs that prefer a bouncy, wobbly toy: SodaPup Magnum Can (choose Rumbl instead)
