Quick answer

Choose Small Stahl for a slimmer, tapered shape with a longer usable length, or Small Eisen if you prefer a shorter toy with a wider head and shaft for more fullness.

Size and shape differences matter

Small Stahl measures 5.75 inches total with a 4.8-inch usable length, a 0.9-inch head diameter, and a 1.1-inch widest shaft diameter. Small Eisen is slightly shorter at 5 inches total and 4.5 inches usable, but has a wider 1.1-inch head and 1.4-inch widest shaft. This means Stahl offers more length for deeper play, while Eisen provides a fuller sensation in a compact form.

Both toys are made from Near Clear 31* silicone, which gives a translucent look and a medium-firm feel. The firmness is the same across both models, so your decision comes down to shape and size preference.

Stahl vs Eisen: trade-offs to consider

  • Length vs fullness: Stahl offers nearly an inch more usable length (4.8 vs 4.5 inches), while Eisen gives a wider head and shaft for a fuller sensation.
  • Insertion ease: Stahl's narrower head (0.9 inches) is easier to insert, especially for beginners. Eisen's larger head (1.1 inches) requires more warm-up.
  • Visual appeal: Both are Near Clear 31* silicone, but available colors vary. Check current listings for specific color options like blue-green or peach. Color options change per batch, so browse the shop for the look you want.

Product details at a glance

  • Small Stahl -- Near Clear 31* silicone -- OF-S-128: Small Stahl has a 0.9-inch head diameter and 1.1-inch widest shaft diameter. This slimmer profile makes it easier to insert and ideal for those who prefer gradual stretching.

    Small Stahl -- Near Clear 31* silicone -- OF-S-128

    Small Stahl -- Near Clear 31* silicone -- OF-S-128

  • Small Eisen -- Near Clear 31* silicone -- OF-E-120: Small Eisen has a 1.1-inch head diameter and 1.4-inch widest shaft diameter. The wider head and shaft provide a fuller feeling and more immediate pressure, suiting users who enjoy a thicker toy.

    Small Eisen -- Near Clear 31* silicone -- OF-E-120

    Small Eisen -- Near Clear 31* silicone -- OF-E-120

Which toy fits you?

Best for

  • Small Stahl: Users who want a longer, slimmer toy for gradual stretching or deeper play.
  • Small Eisen: Users who prefer a shorter, thicker toy with a wider head for a fuller sensation.

Not for

  • Small Stahl: Not ideal if you want a very thick or short toy.
  • Small Eisen: Not ideal if you need a longer usable length or a very narrow insertion.