Two natural dry foods, two different nutritional profiles

Symply Fresh Lamb and 80:20 Scottish Salmon, Herring, Haddock & Trout are both complete dry dog foods, but they are built around different proteins and suit different feeding situations. Symply Fresh Lamb is an adult dog recipe made with fresh lamb, oats, and sweet potato, while 80:20 Scottish Fish is an all-lifestages recipe with 80% fish and a high omega-3 level. This comparison sticks to the supplied product records so you can see where the recipes genuinely differ and where the evidence runs out.

What each recipe declares on protein, fat, and omega oils

  • 80:20 Scottish Salmon, Herring, Haddock & Trout: Analytical constituents per 100g: crude protein 38%, crude oils and fats 19%, crude fibre 2%, crude ash 8%, moisture 8%. Contains 3.3% omega-3. The high protein and omega-3 levels are the main nutritional reasons someone would pick this fish recipe over a lamb-based food.

    80:20 Scottish Salmon, Herring, Haddock & Trout

    80:20 Scottish Salmon, Herring, Haddock & Trout

  • Symply Fresh Lamb for All Dog Breeds: Analytical constituents: crude protein 19%, crude fat 13%, crude fibre 4%, crude ash 7.5%, moisture 8%, omega-3 0.3%, omega-6 1.7%. Symply Fresh Lamb is a moderate-protein, moderate-fat recipe with much lower omega-3 than the fish option, which matters if coat or skin support is your priority.

    Symply Fresh Lamb for All Dog Breeds

    Symply Fresh Lamb for All Dog Breeds

Protein sources and ingredient structure

The 80:20 Scottish Fish recipe gets its name from its composition: 80% fish ingredients and 18% vegetable medley. The fish portion includes freshly prepared salmon (31%), dried salmon (19%), dried herring (9%), freshly prepared Scottish salmon (9%), freshly prepared haddock (5%), and freshly prepared trout (5%). Sweet potato replaces grain in this recipe, and the food is described as grain-free but made in a factory that handles grains.

Symply Fresh Lamb takes a different approach. Its composition lists 45.5% lamb (fresh lamb 26%, dried lamb 15%, lamb fat 3%, lamb gravy 1.5%), followed by sweet potato (16%), whole oats (13%), potato (12%), and pea starch. The recipe includes oats and is described as wheat- and gluten-free, using oats that the manufacturer says will not trigger wheat or gluten allergies. Unlike the fish recipe, Symply Fresh Lamb is not grain-free because of the oats.

Key differences at a glance

  • Life stage: 80:20 Scottish Fish is a complete food for all lifestages. Symply Fresh Lamb is a complete and balanced food for adult dogs.
  • Main protein: 80:20 Scottish Fish uses four fish proteins: salmon, herring, haddock, and trout. Symply Fresh Lamb uses lamb as its single animal protein.
  • Grain: 80:20 Scottish Fish is grain-free, with sweet potato as the main carbohydrate. Symply Fresh Lamb contains whole oats and is wheat- and gluten-free but not grain-free.
  • Omega-3: 80:20 Scottish Fish declares 3.3% omega-3. Symply Fresh Lamb declares 0.3% omega-3.
  • Pack sizes: 80:20 Scottish Fish is available in 2kg, 10kg, and 13.5kg. Symply Fresh Lamb is available in 2kg, 6kg, and 12kg.

When the fish recipe makes more sense

The 80:20 Scottish Fish recipe is the stronger choice if you are feeding a puppy or a dog of mixed ages, because it is labelled for all lifestages. It also has a clear edge if coat condition, skin health, or joint stiffness are your reasons for changing food. The recipe includes 3.3% omega-3, which the product record describes as meaningfully higher than most dry foods, and it includes a joint support pack with glucosamine, chondroitin, and MSM. Those ingredients are supplied facts, not a treatment claim, so treat them as nutritional support rather than a fix for a medical problem.

If your dog has been on a low-fish or grain-inclusive diet and has a dull coat, reactive skin, or stiffness after walks, the product information suggests switching to a food with a serious omega-3 profile as a reasonable first move before considering supplements. That is the manufacturer's positioning, and it is worth discussing with your vet if your dog has a diagnosed condition.

When Symply Fresh Lamb is the better fit

Symply Fresh Lamb is designed for adult dogs and uses a single animal protein, lamb, which can be useful if you are deliberately avoiding fish or rotating proteins. The recipe is described as easy to digest, with prebiotics for healthy digestion, and it is wheat- and gluten-free. Its lower fat level (13%) compared with the fish recipe (19%) may suit dogs who do well on a moderate-fat diet, though the record does not make weight-management claims beyond advising you to reduce food intake by 10% if your dog looks overweight and increase by 10% if underweight.

The lamb recipe also includes oats, so it is not suitable if you are specifically looking for a grain-free food. If your dog has a confirmed wheat or gluten sensitivity, the manufacturer states the oats used will not trigger wheat or gluten allergies, but this is a general statement rather than a guarantee for every dog.

Feeding guidance and transition notes from the records

  • 80:20 Scottish Salmon, Herring, Haddock & Trout: When changing foods, introduce gradually over a period of two weeks. Store in a cool, dry place. Always ensure fresh, clean water is available. A slow transition is especially important when moving between very different protein and fat levels, such as from a lamb recipe to a high-fish recipe.
  • Symply Fresh Lamb for All Dog Breeds: When feeding Symply for the first time, introduce it gradually over 1 week: day one mix 25% Symply with 75% of the previous food, day three 50/50, day five 75% Symply, and 100% Symply by day seven. Store in a cool dry place. The lamb recipe gives a specific one-week transition schedule, which is useful if you are switching to it from another food.

Practical points before you choose

  • Check the life stage: If you have a puppy under 12 months, the 80:20 fish recipe is labelled for all lifestages, while Symply Fresh Lamb is for adult dogs only.
  • Match the pack to your storage space: The fish recipe comes in 2kg, 10kg, and 13.5kg, while the lamb comes in 2kg, 6kg, and 12kg. Choose a size you can store in a cool, dry place and use within the best-before period.
  • Consider protein rotation: If your dog has been on chicken or lamb and you want to try a fish-based food, the 80:20 recipe offers four fish proteins. If you want to avoid fish, Symply Fresh Lamb is a single-protein alternative.
  • Introduce gradually: Both records advise a gradual transition, but the timelines differ: two weeks for the fish recipe and one week for the lamb recipe. Follow the guidance on the pack you choose.

What the records do not settle

Neither product record provides a full feeding chart for every weight and life stage in the supplied evidence, so you will need to use the guide on the back of the pack and adjust for your dog's breed, age, temperament, and activity level. The records also do not confirm whether either recipe is suitable for dogs with specific medical conditions, and they do not include veterinary claims. If your dog has a diagnosed health issue, ask your vet before changing food. Finally, the fish recipe record notes it is made in a factory that handles grains, which is relevant if cross-contamination is a concern for your dog.