Quick answer
Choose the Spellweaver pin if you want a larger, more detailed piece that stands out on a jacket or bag. Pick the Tinkerer pin if you prefer a compact, affordable design that still captures the character's essence.
Size and presence matter for display
The Spellweaver pin is 2 inches across, making it noticeably larger than the 1.5-inch Tinkerer pin. If you plan to wear the pin on a backpack or display it in a shadow box, the Spellweaver will command more attention. The Tinkerer's smaller size works well for lapels or tighter spaces where a subtle touch is better.
Both pins use high-quality synthetic hard enamel and are cast in black nickel, so the finish and durability are identical. The difference comes down to how much visual weight you want the pin to carry.
Price reflects the size difference
The Spellweaver pin is priced at USD 6.49, while the Tinkerer pin costs USD 5.99. Both are marked down from a catalog comparison price of USD 9.99, so you're getting a deal either way. The extra 50 cents for the Spellweaver gets you a half-inch more pin, which is a fair trade for collectors who prioritize scale.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Pick the Spellweaver if you want a larger, more prominent pin: At 2 inches, it is the bigger of the two. It costs USD 6.49, which is only 50 cents more than the Tinkerer. The extra size makes it a better choice for display or for wearing on a bag where you want the design to be visible from a distance.
- Pick the Tinkerer if you value compactness and a slightly lower price: At 1.5 inches, it is more discreet and fits on smaller surfaces like a shirt collar or beanie. It costs USD 5.99, making it the more budget-friendly option while still delivering the same enamel quality and black nickel finish.
- Both pins share the same build quality and backing: Both use high-quality synthetic hard enamel, are cast in black nickel, and come with rubber backing clasps. Neither is objectively better in construction; the choice is purely about size preference and which character you connect with more. Consider which Gloomhaven class you favor most—the Spellweaver's arcane theme or the Tinkerer's inventive gadgets—as personal attachment can be the deciding factor.
Product facts at a glance
-
Spellweaver Collectors Pin: 2-inch collectors pin by Cephalofair Games, high-quality synthetic hard enamel, cast in black nickel, rubber backing clasps. The larger size makes the Spellweaver pin a bolder display piece, ideal for collectors who want their pin to be easily seen.
Spellweaver Collectors Pin
-
Tinkerer Collectors Pin: 1.5-inch collectors pin by Cephalofair Games, high-quality synthetic hard enamel, cast in black nickel, rubber backing clasps. The Tinkerer pin's smaller footprint fits neatly on lapels, hats, or tighter spaces while still offering the same durable enamel construction.
Tinkerer Collectors Pin
Which pin fits your collection?
Best for
- Collectors who want a larger, more eye-catching pin that stands out on a jacket or display board
- Fans of the Spellweaver class who prefer a bigger canvas for the character's design
Not for
- Collectors who need a smaller pin for tight spaces like a hat brim or lapel
- Anyone on a tight budget who wants the lowest price point
