Quick answer

If you prefer gentle, yielding textures with variety, choose Toby. If you want a denser, more pronounced sensation, go with Pipsqueak. The main tradeoff is softness versus firmness, and your personal play style decides the winner.

Silicone firmness and play feel

Silicone firmness directly affects how a toy feels during use. Softer silicone bends and compresses more, creating a gentler sensation that can be easier on sensitive areas. Firmer silicone holds its shape and transfers texture more intensely, giving you a more pronounced, stimulating experience.

Toby uses a body-safe, platinum-cure silicone that is formulated to be soft and pliable. This allows its dual tunnels—each with unique ridges—to flex and adapt, making the texture feel more subtle and forgiving. Pipsqueak, on the other hand, is made from a firmer silicone blend that keeps its structure, so every ridge and bump presses more firmly against you.

There is no right or wrong firmness—only what feels best for your body. If you are new to fantasy toys or prefer a more relaxed session, softer silicone like Toby's can be more comfortable. If you enjoy intense, focused stimulation, firmer silicone like Pipsqueak's may be more satisfying.

Texture and design differences

Toby's design is inspired by an anthropomorphic canine form and offers two distinct penetrable tunnels: a vagina and an anus, playfully styled as a “cookie” and “donut.” Each tunnel has its own pattern of stimulating ridges, giving you variety in a single toy. The soft silicone lets those ridges move with you, creating a dynamic, less predictable feel.

Pipsqueak is a simpler, single-tunnel design with a firmer build. Its texture is more consistent and direct because the silicone does not compress as much. This makes it easier to feel every detail of the internal texture, which some users prefer for targeted stimulation.

The tradeoff is clear: Toby offers variety and softness, while Pipsqueak offers intensity and consistency. If you like switching sensations during a session, Toby's dual tunnels are a clear advantage. If you want a reliable, intense texture every time, Pipsqueak delivers.

Cleaning and maintenance considerations

Both toys are made from platinum-cure silicone, which is non-porous and easy to clean with warm water and mild soap or a dedicated toy cleaner. Softer silicone can attract more lint and dust, so store Toby in a dust-free bag or container. Firmer silicone like Pipsqueak's is less sticky and stays cleaner between uses.

Because Toby has two tunnels, you need to rinse and dry both thoroughly to prevent moisture buildup. Pipsqueak's single tunnel is quicker to clean. Neither toy requires special care beyond standard silicone maintenance, but the softer material may show wear from fingernails or rough handling more easily.

If you share toys with a partner, Toby's dual-tunnel design allows for shared use—each person can use a different entrance. Just be sure to clean between uses or use a condom for hygiene. Pipsqueak is better suited for solo play or single-user scenarios.

Tradeoffs at a glance

  • Soft vs firm silicone: Toby uses softer platinum-cure silicone that compresses easily, creating a gentle, yielding sensation. Pipsqueak uses firmer silicone that holds its shape, delivering more intense texture. Choose soft for comfort and variety; choose firm for intensity and precision.
  • Dual tunnels vs single tunnel: Toby offers two textured tunnels (vagina and anus) with different ridge patterns. Pipsqueak has one tunnel with consistent texture. Toby suits users who want options; Pipsqueak suits those who prefer a focused, repeatable sensation.
  • Ease of cleaning: Toby's two tunnels require thorough drying to prevent moisture. Pipsqueak's single tunnel is quicker to clean and less prone to lint attraction. If low maintenance matters, Pipsqueak is simpler. If variety matters more, the extra cleaning is worth it.

Product facts

  • Toby: Toby is an anthropomorphic-canine-inspired fantasy stroker crafted from body-safe, platinum-cure silicone. It features two distinct penetrable tunnels, a vagina and an anus, stylized as a playful “cookie” and “donut.” Both tunnels are deeply textured with stimulating ridges, each offering a unique pattern for variety. The soft silicone and dual tunnels give you two different texture experiences in one toy, making it ideal for users who enjoy variety and a gentler feel.

Which one fits you?

Best for

  • Users who prefer soft, yielding sensations and want texture variety in one toy
  • People new to fantasy strokers or those with sensitive skin who enjoy a gentler feel

Not for

  • Users who want intense, firm stimulation and prefer a consistent texture every session
  • Those who prioritize quick, low-maintenance cleaning over having multiple tunnel options