Quick answer
Both Open Farm wet foods are complete and balanced meals, but the Turkey & Salmon Hearty Stew suits dogs who prefer a classic meat-and-gravy texture, while the Icelandic Salmon & Cod is a premium seafood option with certified sustainable fish and human-grade ingredients.
Protein sources and what they mean for your dog
The main difference comes down to animal proteins. The Turkey & Salmon Hearty Stew pairs humanely raised turkey with OceanWise® recommended salmon, giving you a mix of poultry and fish. The Icelandic Salmon & Cod uses only fish: ASC certified salmon and MSC certified cod, both sourced from Iceland.
Turkey is a lean protein that many dogs find easy to digest, while salmon adds omega-3 fatty acids that support skin and coat health. Cod is a white fish that's lower in fat and also provides omega-3s, making the Icelandic recipe a great option for dogs who need a lighter protein source.
If your dog has a known sensitivity to poultry, the Icelandic Salmon & Cod is the safer choice. If your dog enjoys variety and you want a stew texture with meaty chunks, the Turkey & Salmon option delivers that classic hearty feel.
Texture and how you serve it
Both products are wet foods, but they differ in presentation. The Turkey & Salmon Hearty Stew features hearty chunks in a rich gravy, which is ideal for dogs who like to chew and for mixing with kibble as a topper. The Icelandic Salmon & Cod is also a complete meal, but the description emphasizes its irresistible flavor and superfoods like sweet potato, suggesting a smoother or finer texture that may appeal to picky eaters.
Consider your dog's eating style. If they gulp food quickly, a chunkier stew may encourage slower eating. If they are older or have dental issues, a softer, more uniform texture might be easier to manage.
Ingredient transparency and sourcing
Open Farm emphasizes traceability and responsible sourcing in both recipes. The Turkey & Salmon Hearty Stew is grain-free and made with 100% traceable ingredients, which is reassuring if you like to know exactly what's in your dog's bowl. The Icelandic Salmon & Cod goes a step further with 100% human-grade ingredients and is made in a human-grade facility, plus it carries ASC and MSC certifications for sustainable seafood.
If you prioritize certified sustainable seafood and human-grade preparation, the Icelandic Salmon & Cod is the stronger pick. If you want a grain-free option with a mix of proteins and traceable sourcing, the Turkey & Salmon Hearty Stew fits the bill.
Trade-offs to consider
- Protein variety vs. single-source fish: Turkey & Salmon gives you two proteins, which can help prevent food boredom and provide a broader amino acid profile. Icelandic Salmon & Cod is fish-only, which is better for dogs with poultry allergies. If your dog has never had cod, introduce it gradually to watch for any sensitivity.
- Texture: chunky stew vs. smoother meal: The Hearty Stew's chunks and gravy are great for dogs who like to chew and for topping kibble. The Icelandic recipe's softer consistency may be easier for seniors or dogs with dental issues. Observe how your dog eats; if they gulp, a chunkier texture may slow them down.
- Sustainability and ingredient standards: Icelandic Salmon & Cod carries ASC and MSC certifications and is 100% human-grade. Turkey & Salmon is grain-free and traceable but doesn't have those seafood certifications. If sustainable seafood is a must, choose the Icelandic option.
Product facts at a glance
-
Turkey & Salmon Hearty Stew Wet Dog Food: Made with humanely raised turkey and OceanWise® recommended salmon plus non-GMO vegetables, grain-free and crafted with 100% traceable ingredients. This gives you a meat-and-fish combo with a hearty, chunky texture that works as a complete meal or a topper.
Turkey & Salmon Hearty Stew Wet Dog Food
-
Icelandic Salmon & Cod Wet Food for Dogs: Made with Icelandic ASC certified salmon and MSC certified cod, combined with non-GMO superfoods like sweet potato, and made in a human grade facility with 100% human grade ingredients. You get a premium, sustainably sourced seafood-only recipe that's ideal for dogs who need a novel protein or prefer a softer texture.
Icelandic Salmon & Cod Wet Food for Dogs
Which one fits your dog?
Best for
- Dogs who enjoy a hearty, chunky texture and a mix of poultry and fish
- Owners who want a grain-free meal with traceable ingredients and the option to use it as a topper
Not for
- Dogs with poultry sensitivities or those who need a single-source protein diet
