Quick answer

Choose the Vantage Metal Coins if you play Vantage and want a precise, affordable upgrade for up to six players. Pick the Scythe & Expeditions Metal Coins if you own Scythe or Expeditions and want a larger, more varied denomination set with distinctive red $5 coins.

What each set offers

The Vantage Metal Coins include 45 zinc coins in four denominations: $1 (x18), $2 (x12), $5 (x9), and $10 (x6). They were designed specifically for the cooperative adventure game Vantage, and one pack covers the needs of a full six-player game. The set is priced at USD 14.20 (compared to USD 20.00), making it a budget-friendly upgrade.

The Scythe & Expeditions Metal Coins contain 80 coins in five denominations: $1, $3, $5, $10, and $20. They are designed for both Scythe and Expeditions, with artwork by Jakub Rozalski. The $5 coins now have a distinct red hue to improve differentiation from the $10 coins. This set costs USD 23.80 (compared to USD 35.00).

Key differences at a glance

Coin count: The Scythe set has 80 coins versus 45 for Vantage. If you need more coins for larger games or multiple sessions, the Scythe set gives you more flexibility.

Denominations: Vantage uses $1, $2, $5, and $10, while Scythe adds a $3 and $20 coin. The extra denominations can simplify transactions in games with varied currency values.

Design: The Scythe coins feature custom artwork tied to the game's world, and the red $5 coins help avoid confusion. The Vantage coins are functional and match the game's theme, but are made of zinc rather than a heavier metal.

Trade-offs to consider

  • Coin count: The Scythe set has 80 coins, nearly double the Vantage set's 45. If you play games with many players or need spare coins, the Scythe set offers more. Vantage is sufficient for its game; Scythe gives you extra for other uses.
  • Denominations: Scythe includes $3 and $20 coins, which can speed up transactions in games with odd values. Vantage sticks to standard $1, $2, $5, and $10. More denominations help in complex economies; simpler denominations work for straightforward games.
  • Price per coin: Vantage costs about $0.32 per coin, while Scythe costs about $0.30 per coin. Both are affordable, but Vantage's lower total price may appeal to budget-conscious buyers. Both are good value; choose based on total cost or coin count needs.

Product details

  • Vantage Metal Coins: 45 metal coins designed specifically for Vantage, including $1 (x18), $2 (x12), $5 (x9), and $10 (x6) coins made of zinc. One pack covers a full 6-player game. You get exactly the coins you need for Vantage without extras, and the lower price makes it an easy upgrade.
  • 80 Metal Coins (Scythe & Expeditions): 80 custom metal coins designed for Expeditions and Scythe, with denominations of $1, $3, $5, $10, and $20. The $5 coins have a distinct red hue to differentiate them from $10 coins. The larger set and extra denominations give you more flexibility for different games, and the color-coded $5 coin reduces confusion during play.

Which set should you buy?

Best for

  • Players who own Vantage and want a precise, cost-effective upgrade for their game
  • Gamers who want a smaller, lighter coin set for travel or storage

Not for

  • Players who need a large coin supply for multiple games or high-player-count sessions
  • Fans of Scythe or Expeditions who want custom artwork and extra denominations