Quick answer

Choose the bundle for maximum variety (beef, chicken, salmon, tuna in jelly) if your cat enjoys different proteins; pick the bumper pack for a meaty gravy option with fewer flavors (beef, chicken, lamb, turkey) at a lower price per pouch.

Variety vs. consistency

The bundle offers four different proteins (beef, chicken, salmon, tuna) in a jelly base, giving you 72 pouches total. The bumper pack also has four proteins (beef, chicken, lamb, turkey) but in a gravy base, with 40 pouches. If your cat prefers jelly or needs more rotation, the bundle wins. If gravy is a must and you want fewer pouches to store, the bumper pack is simpler.

Cost per pouch and value

At the catalog comparison price, the bundle costs about $0.28 per pouch ($20.06/72) and the bumper pack about $0.26 per pouch ($10.23/40). The bundle gives you a lower per-pouch price if you buy on the comparison price, but the bumper pack's actual price is slightly higher per pouch. However, the bundle's higher total cost ($20.06 vs $10.23) means you commit more upfront. For a smaller household, the bumper pack may be more practical.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • Bundle (72 pouches, jelly): More pouches and proteins (salmon, tuna) in jelly. Higher total cost but lower per-pouch price on comparison. Best for multi-cat homes or cats that need variety in jelly.
  • Bumper pack (40 pouches, gravy): Fewer pouches with lamb and turkey in gravy. Lower upfront cost but slightly higher per-pouch price. Best for single-cat households or cats that prefer gravy.
  • Choosing between them: Consider your cat's texture preference (jelly vs gravy) and how many pouches you can store. Both are grain-free and complete meals.

Product facts

Which pack is right for you?

Best for

  • Cats that enjoy a variety of proteins and jelly texture
  • Multi-cat households that can use 72 pouches before expiry
  • Owners who want the lowest per-pouch price on comparison

Not ideal for

  • Cats that only eat gravy-based food
  • Single-cat homes with limited storage space
  • Owners on a tighter budget who prefer a lower upfront cost