Quick answer

Choose the 6-pack of White Cheddar Shells for a creamy, classic mac experience, or the 12-pack of Yellow Cheddar Elbows for more servings and a sharper cheese flavor.

Shape and cheese matter more than you think

Both options combine wheat and chickpea protein for a familiar pasta texture with extra protein. But the shape and cheese type change how the dish feels and tastes. Shells hold more sauce inside each piece, giving you a creamier bite. Elbows offer a more traditional mac and cheese shape that many kids and adults already love.

Pack size and value

The 6-pack of shells is priced at $26.99 (compare at $35.99), making it a great entry point if you want to try a new shape. The 12-pack of elbows costs $40.79 (compare at $59.99), which gives you more servings per dollar. If you feed a larger family or plan to eat mac and cheese often, the 12-pack offers better value.

Shells vs Elbows: tradeoffs at a glance

  • White Cheddar Shells (6-Pack): Creamier sauce retention due to shell shape. White cheddar flavor is milder and smoother. 6-pack is a lower upfront cost. Best if you want a creamy, indulgent mac experience and are okay with fewer servings.
  • Yellow Cheddar Elbows (12-Pack): Traditional elbow shape with sharper yellow cheddar. 12-pack offers more servings per dollar. Familiar taste for picky eaters. Best for larger households or frequent mac and cheese eaters who want a classic flavor.
  • Which one is healthier?: Both have the same wheat-and-chickpea protein base, so protein and fiber content are similar. The difference is purely shape, cheese, and pack size.

Product facts at a glance

  • Wheat Protein Mac and Cheese Shells – White Cheddar (6-Pack): Wheat Protein Mac and Cheese Shells – White Cheddar (6-Pack) brings together wheat & chickpeas for classic taste and a boost of protein. The shell shape traps creamy white cheddar sauce, giving each bite a richer mouthfeel.

    Wheat Protein Mac and Cheese Shells – White Cheddar (6-Pack)

    Wheat Protein Mac and Cheese Shells – White Cheddar (6-Pack)

  • Wheat Protein Mac and Cheese Elbows – Yellow Cheddar (12-Pack): Wheat Protein Mac and Cheese Elbows – Yellow Cheddar (12-Pack) combines wheat & chickpeas for classic taste and a protein boost. The elbow shape and yellow cheddar deliver a familiar, sharper cheese flavor that kids often prefer.

    Wheat Protein Mac and Cheese Elbows – Yellow Cheddar (12-Pack)

    Wheat Protein Mac and Cheese Elbows – Yellow Cheddar (12-Pack)

Which one fits you?

Best for

  • Families who want a creamier, sauce-filled mac and cheese experience (choose Shells)
  • Larger households or meal preppers who want more servings at a lower per-serving cost (choose Elbows)

Not for

  • Anyone who strongly prefers one cheese flavor over the other – white cheddar is milder, yellow cheddar is sharper