Quick Answer
Choose the XL Sunshine if you want a rot-proof, low-maintenance roof that lasts for decades. Choose the XL Cottage (ex-display) if you prefer a lower upfront cost and don't mind standard wood roofing that needs occasional treatment.
Why the Roof Material Matters Most
The biggest difference between these two 6-8 bird coops is the roof. The XL Sunshine uses an ECO plastic roof that is rot-free and requires no maintenance, while the XL Cottage has a standard wooden roof. Since the roof faces the harshest weather, choosing the right material can save you time and effort over the years.
Both coops share a similar layout: a metal lined pull out tray for easy cleaning, a large front door with an access ramp and ventilation window, plus a huge rear door for you to reach inside. The core structure and capacity are nearly identical, so the decision really comes down to roof preference and budget.
XL Sunshine vs XL Cottage: Trade-offs
- Roof Durability: XL Sunshine has ECO plastic roof that is rot-free and maintenance-free. XL Cottage has standard wooden roof that will need periodic treatment.
- Upfront Cost: XL Cottage (ex-display) is priced at USD 200.99, while XL Sunshine costs USD 230.99. The difference reflects the roof material and condition (ex-display vs new). If you're on a tighter budget, the ex-display Cottage saves you money up front.
- Long-term Maintenance: Sunshine's plastic roof never needs painting or sealing. The Cottage's wood roof will require annual or bi-annual treatment to prevent rot. Over 5+ years, the Sunshine's total cost may be lower because you avoid recurring maintenance expenses.
Product Facts at a Glance
-
XL Sunshine 6-8 Birds Chicken Coop: The roofs are made of ECO plastic which is rot free and offers no maintenance. You can keep the coop outdoors without needing to treat or replace the roof for decades.
XL Sunshine 6-8 Birds Chicken Coop
-
XL Cottage 6-8 Birds Chicken Coop (Ex-Display): The XL Cottage 6-8 Birds Chicken Coop (Ex-Display) has a metal lined pull out tray for easy cleaning. The ex-display designation means it's available at a reduced price, making it a more budget-friendly entry into a quality 6-8 bird house.
XL Cottage 6-8 Birds Chicken Coop (Ex-Display)
Which One Should You Choose?
Best For
- Backyard keepers who want the lowest long-term maintenance
- Anyone who can't or doesn't want to treat wood roofs regularly
- Buyers who prefer a new, non-ex-display product
Not Recommended For
- Shoppers looking for the cheapest possible 6-8 bird coop (consider the ex-display Cottage instead)
- Those who want a classic wooden roof aesthetic and are willing to maintain it
