Quick answer

If you want a diaper that contains messes like a disposable, choose the Classic Camper with its dirty closure snaps. If you prefer the convenience of a zipper closure, go with Zippies. Both are one-size pocket diapers that fit 8-35 lbs, but the closure system is the key difference.

Closure Systems: Zippies vs. Classic Camper

The main difference between Zippies and Classic Camper pocket diapers is how they close. Classic Camper diapers use dirty closure snaps that let you roll up a soiled diaper similar to a disposable, trapping the mess inside. Zippies, on the other hand, feature a zipper closure for a quick, secure seal. Both systems work well, but your preference for snapping or zipping will guide your choice.

Fit and Sizing

Both Zippies and Classic Camper are one-size pocket diapers designed to fit babies from approximately 8 to 35 pounds. They have a wide pocket opening (5 cm) for easy stuffing, and the tummy panel insert is not included. The inside lining is gray AWJ (Athletic Wicking Jersey), which helps keep moisture away from baby's skin. The adjustable snap settings allow you to customize the fit as your baby grows.

Trade-offs to consider

  • Classic Camper: Dirty closure snaps: Snaps let you roll up a soiled diaper like a disposable, trapping odor and mess. They also provide additional sizing options. However, snapping takes a moment longer than zipping. Best if you want a familiar, disposable-like containment method.
  • Zippies: Zipper closure: Zippers offer a fast, one-motion seal. They are intuitive and quick, but if the zipper breaks, the diaper may be harder to use. Zippies may also be slightly bulkier in the laundry. Best if you prioritize speed and convenience over the snap-and-roll method.
  • Both: One-size pocket design: Both diapers fit 8-35 lbs with adjustable snaps and a 5 cm pocket opening. Neither includes a tummy panel insert, so you'll need to buy inserts separately. The gray AWJ lining is consistent across both. Both are versatile, long-lasting options for most babies.

Product facts at a glance

  • Cheetah Rainbow One Size Pocket- In stock: One Size Pocket fits babies approximately 8-35 lbs. Inside Lining -Gray AWJ Dirty Closure Snaps- Can be used to close up those stinky diapers (similar to rolling up a disposable diaper) or can be used for additional sizing. Wide Pocket Opening 5cm Tummy Panel Insert Not Included Prints And Bums May Vary! The dirty closure snaps let you contain messes without touching them, making diaper changes cleaner and easier.
  • Cactus Summer-OS: One Size Pocket fits babies approximately 8-35 lbs. Inside Lining -Gray AWJ Dirty Closure Snaps- Can be used to close up those stinky diapers (similar to rolling up a disposable diaper) or can be used for additional sizing. Wide Pocket Opening 5cm Tummy Panel Insert Not Included This Classic Camper option offers the same snap closure and wide pocket for easy stuffing, with a slightly lower price point.

Which one should you choose?

Best for

  • Parents who want a disposable-like containment method with dirty closure snaps
  • Budget-conscious shoppers looking for a reliable one-size pocket diaper

Not for

  • Parents who prefer a zipper closure for faster diaper changes
  • Those who need a diaper with a built-in tummy panel insert