Quick answer

For smaller pans (20–24 cm) that double as a colander, choose the SMART & COMPACT Escurridor & Tapa antisalpicaduras. For taller pots (24–28 cm) where splatter reduction is the main goal, the SMART & COMPACT Tapa antisalpicaduras alto is the better fit.

Size and compatibility matter first

Both accessories are designed to fit specific Kuhn Rikon pan diameters. The SMART & COMPACT Escurridor & Tapa antisalpicaduras works with 20 cm and 24 cm pans. The SMART & COMPACT Tapa antisalpicaduras alto fits 24 cm and 28 cm pots and pans. If your cookware is on the smaller side, the first option is your only match; if you use larger or taller pots, the second one is necessary.

The height of the pan also influences the choice. The Tapa antisalpicaduras alto is built for high pots, meaning it sits taller above the pan rim. This design helps contain splatter from deeper cooking, such as soups or stews, where a standard flat lid might not seal as effectively.

Dual function vs. dedicated splatter control

The Escurridor & Tapa antisalpicaduras offers a dual-purpose design: it works as a colander and a splatter cover. If you often drain pasta or vegetables in the same pan, this accessory saves you from buying a separate colander. The trade-off is that its draining holes may let small amounts of splatter escape when used as a lid.

The Tapa antisalpicaduras alto is a dedicated splatter guard with no draining function. Its solid construction (without holes) provides better splatter containment, especially for high-sided pots. You lose the colander feature, but you gain more reliable mess reduction during simmering or frying.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • SMART & COMPACT Escurridor & Tapa antisalpicaduras Ø 20 / 24 cm: Dual colander and splatter guard. Fits 20 cm and 24 cm pans. Best if you need one tool for draining and covering.
  • SMART & COMPACT Tapa antisalpicaduras alto Ø 24 / 28 cm: Dedicated anti-splash lid for high pots. Fits 24 cm and 28 cm diameters. Provides better splatter control for deeper cooking.
  • Key trade-off: The colander/splatter guard adds versatility but may allow minor splatter through its holes. The dedicated lid offers superior splatter reduction but no draining function. Match the accessory to your primary cooking task: versatility vs. mess control.

Product facts

Which one fits your pan?

Best for

  • Owners of 20 cm or 24 cm pans who want a single accessory for draining and splatter reduction
  • Home cooks who frequently boil pasta or steam vegetables in the same pan

Not for

  • Those with 28 cm or taller pots who need maximum splatter containment
  • Cooks who prefer a dedicated lid without draining holes for heavy simmering