Quick answer
If you prefer a bold, skull-themed design with an ancient gold finish, choose the Poison Pin. For a more mysterious, society-inspired look with gold plating, go with the Guild of Thieves Pin.
Design and symbolism
The Poison Pin features the Poison Skull, a striking emblem that leans into darker, edgier aesthetics. Its ancient gold finish gives it a vintage, almost relic-like appearance that stands out on any jacket or bag.
The Guild of Thieves Pin, on the other hand, represents membership in the fictional Guild of Thieves Society. The effigy of the Gentleman Thief, rendered in gold plating with black and white accents, offers a more refined, story-driven appeal.
Size and finish differences
The Poison Pin measures 1.25 inches (about 32mm) and comes in an ancient gold finish. It's compact but visually dense, making it ideal for smaller display areas or as a subtle accent.
The Guild of Thieves Pin is slightly taller at 40mm and available in three colors: gold plated, black, and white. This gives you more options to match your personal style or other accessories.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Poison Pin: bold and compact: If you want a pin that makes a strong visual statement with a skull motif and antique finish, the Poison Pin delivers in a smaller footprint.
- Guild of Thieves Pin: versatile and story-driven: If you value narrative and want a pin that ties into the Guild of Thieves lore, plus the flexibility of three color choices, this is your pick.
- Price consideration: The Guild of Thieves Pin is priced at USD 12.60 (compared to USD 20.00), while the Poison Pin is USD 14.80 (also compared to USD 20.00). Both offer good value for a collectible pin. Your budget may slightly favor the Guild of Thieves Pin, but the difference is minimal.
Product details
-
Guild of Thieves Pin: Features the effigy of the Gentleman Thief, height 40mm, available in gold plated, black, and white. The taller size and color options make it easier to coordinate with other pins or accessories.
Guild of Thieves Pin
-
Poison Pin: Features the Poison Skull, size 1.25 inches, ancient gold finish, made by Coins for Anything. The ancient gold finish gives it a distinct vintage look that appeals to collectors who favor darker themes.
Poison Pin
Which pin fits you?
Best for
- Collectors who prefer darker, skull-themed designs with a vintage finish
- Fans of the Poison character or brand lore
Not for
- Those who want a larger pin or multiple color options
- Collectors seeking a more subtle, society-inspired emblem
