Quick Answer
For most Unearth groups, the 4 player play mat is the practical choice—it's compact, affordable, and fits the standard player count. Choose the 6 player mat only if you regularly play with five or six people and have enough table space.
Player Count vs Table Space
The biggest difference between these two mats is how many players they support. The Unearth 4 player play mat is designed for up to four players, while the 6 player version accommodates up to six. If your group rarely exceeds four, the smaller mat saves table space and is easier to store.
But player count isn't the only factor. The 6 player mat is significantly larger (36 by 49 inches) compared to the 4 player mat (43 by 28 inches). That extra width and length means you'll need a bigger table—measure your gaming surface before committing to the larger option.
Price and Value
Price is a clear trade-off. The 4 player mat is listed at $20.10 (compared to $30.00), while the 6 player mat costs $31.95 (compared to $45.00). If you're on a budget or play mostly with three or four friends, the 4 player mat delivers the same Unearth experience for less.
However, if you frequently host larger groups, the 6 player mat's higher price may be justified—it saves you from squeezing five or six players onto a mat designed for four, which can lead to cramped spaces and misplaced pieces.
Durability and Cleaning
Both mats are printed on durable, easy-to-clean vinyl, so you don't have to worry about spills or wear. The scratch-resistant surface keeps the design vibrant even after repeated use. This is a key consideration if your game nights involve snacks or drinks.
The larger 6 player mat covers more surface area, which means more vinyl to clean—but the material is the same, so maintenance is equally simple. Just wipe it down with a damp cloth and it's ready for the next session.
Trade-Offs at a Glance
- Player Count: The 4 player mat supports up to 4 players; the 6 player mat supports up to 6. Choose based on your typical group size. If you rarely have more than 4 players, the 4 player mat avoids wasted space.
- Table Space: The 4 player mat is 43x28 inches; the 6 player mat is 36x49 inches. Measure your table to ensure the larger mat fits comfortably. The 6 player mat needs about 17% more table area—check dimensions first.
- Budget: The 4 player mat costs $20.10; the 6 player mat costs $31.95. The 6 player mat costs about 59% more. If budget is tight and your group is small, the 4 player mat offers the best value.
Product Facts
-
Unearth 4 Player Play Mat: The Unearth 4 Player Play Mat is 43 by 28 inches and printed on durable, easy-to-clean vinyl. Its compact size fits standard tables and makes cleanup quick, ideal for smaller groups.
Unearth 4 Player Play Mat
-
Boss Monster 6 Player Play Mat: The Boss Monster 6 Player Mat is 36 by 49 inches and printed on durable, easy-to-clean vinyl. The larger surface accommodates up to six players but requires a bigger table and more storage space.
Boss Monster 6 Player Play Mat
Which Mat Fits Your Group?
Best For
- Groups of 3-4 players who want a compact, budget-friendly mat
- Players with limited table space who prefer easy storage
Not For
- Groups that regularly play with 5-6 players and have a large table
- Players who prioritize maximum surface area for sprawling games
