Quick answer
Choose the Embrace Newborn Carrier for a dedicated, ergonomic carrier that supports your baby from birth without an insert. Pick the Upsie Sling for a compact, on-the-go sling that works for quick ups and downs with an active young baby or toddler.
Support and intended use
The Embrace Newborn Carrier is designed specifically for newborns and babies up to 12 months. It features a patented, adjustable bucket seat that supports healthy hip positioning and includes padded head and neck support. The Upsie Sling, on the other hand, is a compact assist carrier meant for shorter-term wear. It offers a wide ergonomic seat but is intended for active babies and toddlers who are already sitting up well and need quick carries.
Portability and convenience
The Upsie Sling folds down easily and fits into a diaper bag, making it ideal for errands or trips where you need a carrier that doesn't take up much space. It also has a front pocket for keys and a phone. The Embrace is more structured and doesn't fold as compactly, but it provides more support for longer periods of wear.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Age range: The Embrace is designed for newborns up to 12 months, with a padded head and neck support. The Upsie Sling is intended for active young babies and toddlers who can hold their head up well. If your baby is under 4 months or needs full head support, choose the Embrace.
- Carry style: The Embrace offers two ergonomic positions (inward and outward). The Upsie Sling is a two-position sling but is meant for shorter periods of wear. For longer walks or all-day wear, the Embrace is more comfortable. For quick trips, the Upsie Sling is lighter.
- Portability: The Upsie Sling folds down to fit in a diaper bag. The Embrace is more structured and less compact. If you need a carrier to stash in a bag for emergencies, the Upsie Sling wins.
Key differences at a glance
-
Embrace Newborn Carrier - Knit: Awarded 'The Best Baby Carrier for Newborns' by the NY Times Wirecutter; newborn-ready with no infant insert required. You can use it from day one without buying extra accessories, and it provides industry-leading ergonomic support for healthy hip development.
Embrace Newborn Carrier - Knit
-
Upsie Sling Carrier: Compact two-position sling carrier that folds down easily for on-the-go use, with a front pocket for keys and phone. It is perfect for quick carries when you need your hands free briefly, and it stores easily in a diaper bag or stroller basket.
Upsie Sling Carrier
Which one fits your life?
Best for
- Parents who want a dedicated newborn carrier with full ergonomic support from birth without extra inserts.
- Parents who plan to use a carrier for longer periods or walks.
Not ideal for
- Parents who need a compact carrier for quick trips and already have a structured carrier for longer wear.
