Quick answer

Both Tom's of Maine Whole Care Peppermint and Wintermint natural toothpastes deliver the same cavity-fighting fluoride and enamel-strengthening benefits. The only real difference is the flavor: Peppermint offers a classic, bright mint taste, while Wintermint provides a cooler, slightly sweeter experience. Choose based on your personal flavor preference.

Same formula, different flavor

Both the Peppermint and Wintermint versions of Tom's of Maine Whole Care Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride share the same active ingredient (fluoride) and the same core benefits: cavity prevention, enamel strengthening, and surface stain removal for whiter teeth. The only difference listed on the packaging is the flavor. This means your choice comes down entirely to which mint profile you enjoy more.

If you are sensitive to strong mint sensations, the Wintermint may feel gentler. If you prefer a traditional, invigorating mint that leaves your mouth feeling ultra-clean, Peppermint is the classic pick.

Trade-offs at a glance

  • Flavor profile: Peppermint: classic, bright, invigorating mint. Wintermint: cooler, slightly sweeter, less sharp mint.
  • Same benefits: Both provide cavity prevention, enamel strengthening, and surface stain removal for whiter teeth.
  • Price & size: Both are 4.0 oz tubes. The Peppermint version is priced at USD 5.19 (catalog comparison price USD 7.99). The Wintermint version is listed at a different price point (USD 567.29 catalog price), which appears to be a listing error; check the current price on the product page. Always verify the current price for the Wintermint variant before purchasing.

Product facts

  • Whole Care Peppermint Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride: Tom's of Maine Whole Care Peppermint Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride is an anticavity toothpaste that prevents cavities, strengthens enamel, and whitens teeth by removing surface stains. You get complete cavity protection and enamel care in a familiar, bright peppermint flavor that many people associate with a thorough clean.

    Whole Care Peppermint Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride

    Whole Care Peppermint Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride

  • Whole Care Wintermint Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride: Tom's of Maine Whole Care Wintermint Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride is an anticavity toothpaste that prevents cavities, strengthens enamel, and whitens teeth by removing surface stains. Wintermint offers a cooler, slightly sweeter mint taste that can feel more refreshing and less sharp than standard peppermint, making it a good option for those who find strong mint overwhelming.

    Whole Care Wintermint Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride

    Whole Care Wintermint Natural Toothpaste with Fluoride

Which one should you choose?

Best for

  • Classic mint lovers who want a traditional, invigorating clean – choose Peppermint.
  • Those who prefer a cooler, slightly sweeter mint that feels gentler on the palate – choose Wintermint.

Not for

  • Anyone seeking a fluoride-free toothpaste or a non-mint flavor – both options contain fluoride and are mint-based.