Quick answer

Choose Pumpkin Kitties if you want a shiny gold-foil finish and a sweeter Halloween look; go with Gals & Ghouls if you prefer a matte, spooky-cute vibe and a slightly lower price.

Art style and mood

Both sheets bring a kawaii twist to Halloween, but the art direction sets them apart. Gals & Ghouls, by @miznawada, leans into a gothic-cute aesthetic with ghostly characters and a darker palette. Pumpkin Kitties, by @cremechii, turns a pumpkin into an adorable cat enjoying trick-or-treat activities — it's pure, playful sweetness.

Finish and durability

The top coating is the biggest functional difference. Pumpkin Kitties has a gold foil finish that catches light and adds a premium feel, while Gals & Ghouls has no top coating, giving it a standard matte appearance. If you plan to use the stickers on items that get handled often, the foil layer on Pumpkin Kitties may hold up better over time.

Gals & Ghouls vs Pumpkin Kitties: Trade-offs

  • Price: Gals & Ghouls costs $2.38 (compared to $3.50), while Pumpkin Kitties is $2.59 (compared to $3.50). Both offer a discount from the comparison price, but Gals & Ghouls is slightly cheaper. If budget is your main concern, Gals & Ghouls saves you about $0.21.
  • Finish: Pumpkin Kitties has a gold foil coating that adds shine and durability; Gals & Ghouls has no coating, so the design remains matte and low-profile. Choose foil for extra pop and protection; choose matte for a subtle, understated look.
  • Art style: Gals & Ghouls offers spooky-cute characters with a gothic edge. Pumpkin Kitties delivers a sweet, whimsical Halloween scene with cats and pumpkins. Match the mood to your project — dark and edgy vs. light and playful.

Product details

  • Gals & Ghouls Sticker Sheet: Gals & Ghouls has no top coating and uses a PVC adhesive layer on a clear PET backing. The matte finish keeps the design flat and subtle, ideal for planners where you don't want extra shine.

    Gals & Ghouls Sticker Sheet

    Gals & Ghouls Sticker Sheet

  • Pumpkin Kitties Sticker Sheet: Pumpkin Kitties features a gold foil top coating over a PVC adhesive layer on a clear PET backing. The foil adds a reflective, premium look that makes the stickers stand out on notebooks, laptops, or water bottles.

    Pumpkin Kitties Sticker Sheet

    Pumpkin Kitties Sticker Sheet

Which sticker sheet is for you?

Best for

  • Gals & Ghouls: collectors and planners who love gothic-kawaii art and want a budget-friendly, matte sticker.
  • Pumpkin Kitties: anyone who wants a shiny, durable sticker with a cute, family-friendly Halloween design.

Not for

  • Gals & Ghouls: if you need a shiny or foil accent to match other embellishments.
  • Pumpkin Kitties: if you prefer a darker, edgier aesthetic or want to avoid metallic finishes.